Friday, April 03, 2009

A word puzzle


While visiting with Ben and Elsa, David Canfield, the composer and collector and brilliant host of their small group, posed us with a grammar challenge. You can make the following words a grammatically correct sentence by adding a total of 11 punctuation marks. Can you do it? I couldn't! Here are the words:

John where Jim had had had had had had had had had had had the teachers approval


Now, add eleven punctuation marks to make sense of it: don't change any words, remove any words, etc.

Good luck! I'll post the answer tomorrow.

4 comments:

Shannon said...

Can you move words around to change the order? Or does that count as changing the words...?
If so, I think I might have it...

Shannon said...

John, where Jim had had "had," had had "had had;" "had had" had had the teacher's approval.

???
Ok. That's my best. :)

MagistraCarminum said...

No, Shannon: no moving around of any words. You must use them in that exact order. The only thing you can do is add punctuation :-)

MagistraCarminum said...

And well done, Shannon! This is the exactly correct answer! I am VERY impressed!